• Is it A Magic Item? > 자유게시판

• 목록
• 답변
• 글쓰기
• 게시판 리스트 옵션
  • 수정
  • 삭제

Short Answer: Ki creates magical results that are subject to Antimagic Field's results.

Discussion

In the boxed part overlaying the Weave (PHB p. 205) ki is overlooked. Since that PHB chapter is about "spells and spell casting" that makes organizational sense.

There's a clue within the shaded field about the Weave that should bridge the gap between the monk and the spell casters. Three points stand out:

1. The worlds inside the D&D multiverse are magical places2. All magic is determined by the Weave, though different kinds of magic access it in a selection of ways.3. The caster plucks immediately at the strands of the Weave to create the specified impact.

Magical Effects (PHB p. 201)

1. A spell is a discrete magical effect.

Putting two factors together all magic depends upon the Weave in order to create magical effects. You may conclude that to create a magical effect you have to entry the Weave.

Ki

This vitality is an element of the magic that suffuses the multiverse -- particularly the element that flows via living bodies. Monks harness this power inside themselves to create magical effects ... utilizing this vitality**, monks channel uncanny pace and strength into their unarmed strikes. (PHB p. 76)

An Antimagic Field's affect

Any active spell or different magical effect on a creature or an object within the sphere is suppressed whereas the creature or object is in it. (p. 214 PHB)

Conclusion

Use Ki to access the magic in the multiverse and create a magical impact is thus topic to the general guidelines on magic arriving through the Weave. That might make a use of Ki magical energy unavailable in an anti-magic field.

Caveat

There are some nuances primarily based on this sage recommendation article the place whether or not a dragon's breath is magical was addressed (the answer was no).

Determining whether a game feature is magical is easy. Ask your self these questions concerning the feature: • Is it a magic item? • Is it a spell? Or does it let you create the results of a spell that’s mentioned in its description? • Is it a spell attack? • Does its description say it’s magical?

This tweet makes use of the same reasoning.

Q: ki is described as magical, however nothing in beautiful strike says that it is magical. Are you able to verify that it is not please?

Jeremy Crawford: Neither the ki characteristic nor the Stunning Strike characteristic (PH, 78 & 79) is outlined as magical for game functions. #DnD

While this seems to be a contradiction, utilizing the template of analyzing why dragon breath isn't magical helps to know where Crawford was coming from in that tweet regarding ki: it isn't 100% of the time magical as a common rule, however some ki results both replicate or create magical effects and thus have to be handled as magical effects.

More RAI/Dev Support

1. As mentioned on this reply, Mike Mearls talks in a D&D podcast about monkish Ki vitality being the identical "kind" of vitality that is often accessed by the Weave: the vitality native to the multiverse. (Credit to @nitsua60 for this dev aspect help to the reply).2. On 12 Sept 2017, Jeremy Crawford made this tweet supporting the same viewpoint.

Q: Do the monk's ki empowered strikes operate when inside an antimagic field?

Jeremy Crawford: The Ki-Empowered Strikes feature says a monk's unarmed strikes count as magical. That magic is suppressed in an antimagic field.

Is it fluff? No.

Antimagic Field (Spell Description)

PHB p. 213: *This area is divorced from the magical power that suffuses the multiverse.*

Based upon how the book describes Ki, patrick’s magic field slot the negation of magical energy and magical effects consists of Ki based mostly magical effects. Even re-fluffing, or decoding, Ki as a unique solution to get at magical vitality than using the Weave will run into the specifics of the spell description.

Ki independent of the Weave would not get around Antimagic Field's features: Ki would be one approach to access that energy to create magical effects, the Weave would be another. Antimagic Field suppresses both kinds of magical effects.

Notes relating to Ki empowered strikes at level 6:

If you make an unarmed strike that has no Ki points spent, you continue to channel Ki to beat resistance or immunity to non magical attacks and damage. (P. 79 PHB) This can be suppressed in an Antimagic Field based mostly on the above reasoning. (Likewise using Ki to channel elemental vitality (p. 80-81 PHB).)

Antimagic Field is critically strong magic: 8th stage spell. Only artifacts and deities get a go. A monk is neither of those.